Order Ahead › Cheese Bagels Image 1 of 3 Image 2 of 3 Image 3 of 3 Cheese Bagels from $4.75 Cheese bagels have fancier pants than classic bagels, and those pants are made of cheese. Bagel: Select Bagel Cheddar and Onion Feta and Garlic White Cheddar and Jalapeño Tomato, Basil + Mozzarella One of each (four total) Add To Cart Added! Cheese bagels have fancier pants than classic bagels, and those pants are made of cheese.